close
close

Apre-salomemanzo

Breaking: Beyond Headlines!

Eating disorders are getting worse. Is it the fault of social networks?
aecifo

Eating disorders are getting worse. Is it the fault of social networks?

“Fat Girl Cheat Codes to Get a Lean Body.” “Activities for Skinny Girls to Live a Skinny Life” “A step-by-step guide on how to get skinny.” These are just a few of the most recent video titles from content creator Liv Schmidt. On YouTube, where Schmidt currently posts, they highlight the creator’s intense focus on thinness, with most of the half-hour to hour-long videos showing Schmidt directly on camera offering advice, like comparing bodies in progress of weight loss to a roller that slowly wears out. of toilet paper or the fact of espousing the usefulness of Bethenny FrankelThe famous motto of “Taste everything, eat nothing”. But online, Schmidt’s content, which has been denounced by medical professionals and banned on TikTok, represents an ongoing battle between tech companies and the stars who make them money. Is skinny back? And if that’s the case, what happens to viewers that this type of content might harm in the process?

Although Schmidt is not a household name, she wields outsized influence. on TikTok. (The influencer and her representatives did not respond to rolling stone(requests for comment from .) Since gaining popularity in 2023, the New York-based 22-year-old has grown her TikTok account to over 600,000 followers by posting videos on how to avoid accidental weight gain in college and stay slim while working. in an office and how to shop while taking your waist size into account. “Weight is a touchy subject, but it’s what viewers want,” she told the TV show. Wall Street Journal in September, fending off criticism, although she did not directly respond to allegations that she promotes disordered eating.

But even though Schmidt and his fans support his videos, TikTok has strict policies against content that can be seen as promoting unrest. She was banned in September and then again in October after trying to start her account from the beginning. When reached for comment, a TikTok spokesperson confirmed that Schmidt’s account had been disabled for violating community guidelines, but declined to specify which specific videos violated the rules. According to TikTok’s Community Guidelines, the company does not allow eating disorders and unsafe weight loss behaviors to be shown or promoted. Content that falls into a gray area – such as weight loss tips, body checking and using medications or supplements for weight loss – is restricted to viewers aged 18 and over and, in some cases , may not be eligible for the page for you. .

But even though Schmidt was banned from TikTok, that didn’t stop her from monetizing her content — and believing that “everyone can be skinny” — on other social media platforms. Since August 25, Schmidt has posted at least 11 videos and vlogs on YouTube about how to exercise, eat and party to get a slim body. Since being banned from TikTok, where she had over 600,000 subscribers, Schmidt’s YouTube account now has 11,000 subscribers. When reached for comment, YouTube said the site “prohibits content that glorifies, promotes, or depicts disordered eating behaviors.” We also do not broadly recommend content that comes close to violating these policies. Liv Schmidt only recently started posting to YouTube and is of course subject to our community guidelines. On Instagram, where Schmidt posts photos for her 67,000 followers, she usually references her diet content. “Follow me for more diet tips, order the whole dessert menu,” she captioned it a message. But on her subscribers-only chat, where she has hundreds of paying customers, Schmidt gives real diet advice, including calorie restriction and exercise. (Meta did not respond to rolling stone(request for comment from .) Even if Schmidt disappears from social media completely, what’s left is a digital landscape that proves eating disorder content isn’t just a trend, it’s in demand. And according to medical experts and researchers who spoke to rolling stoneThis couldn’t have come at a worse time.

Social media has a long history of discussions around body image, mental health and disordered practices, with eating disorder communities proliferate on text-based sites like MySpace and Tumblr. But as popular apps now emphasize visual media, experts say the risks users face from messy practices have changed. “Unfortunately, social media replicates what we see in mainstream media as well as offline patterns. As such, social media often promotes body types that are unattainable for most, which has been shown to negatively impact body image,” says Yalda Uhls, assistant professor at UCLA and founder of the Center for Scholars & Storytellers. “Additionally, there are subgroups that meet on social media and share information that can be harmful, such as (pro-anorexia) groups that talk about not eating.”

But even if experts agree that content that explicitly encourages people to develop eating disorders is wrong, the complex nature of the disease requires tackling the vast majority of content that could being harmful is much more difficult. Renee Engeln, a psychology professor at Northwestern University, says that while social media content can change us, it will also vary from person to person. “Many people can swim in all kinds of toxic content on social media without developing an eating disorder. But if you are vulnerable to developing an eating disorder, social media content may continually push you toward less healthy and more extreme attitudes toward eating, exercise, and body image,” explains Engeln. “People already prone to disordered eating attitudes and behaviors tend to seek out content focused on body shape, dieting, and exercise. The more you search for this content, the more the algorithms will continue to serve it to you.

Social media and technological advancements are often accused of provoking fatalistic or unwanted reactions among their users. But even though doctors say the cause of eating disorders can vary, what is undoubtedly true is that eating disorders in adolescents are getting worse. According to data from the Centers for Disease Control, hospitalizations for eating disorders among teenage girls have doubled during the pandemic. The National Eating Disorders Association (NEDA) found that more than nine percent of Americans will experience an eating disorder in their lifetime, a rate that has seen a steady increase over the past 10 years. And as a psychiatric illness, eating disorders have the second highest mortality rate. The only thing waiting for them is opiate addiction. “It is not uncommon for someone who searches for information online to then be exposed to content that could then be harmful to them or put them at increased risk of an eating disorder,” says CEO Doreen Marshall of NEDA. rolling stone. “We encourage content creators to promote resources and information about seeking help, share hope for recovery, and refrain from sharing images or behaviors that may fuel eating disorders in groups vulnerable.”

Many advocates for people with eating disorders have directly called on tech companies to help solve the problem. Since 2020, US lawmakers have criticized companies like Meta, TikTok, Snapchat and Google for their algorithms would have been boosted Eating disorder content. Bryn Austin, professor at Harvard University’s TH Chan School of Public Health, says rolling stone that while practitioners can offer help to people suffering from disorders, a stronger approach to technology is needed to really make a difference. In 2024, TikTok expanded its rules against promoting unhealthy eating habits, including blocking particularly egregious accounts from monetizing content and age-restricting other versions. But Austin says there is still much work to be done across the board. “We need to change the law, plain and simple. Nearly 30 years ago, Silicon Valley lobbyists won broad protections for the industry, codified in federal law – Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act. This effectively shut down almost all efforts to hold social media platforms accountable,” she says. “But it was only a few months ago that we saw signs of change, when the Third Circuit Court ruled that TikTok could potentially be held liable for a viral trend… linked to the self-strangulation death of a child 10 years old. The move has given momentum to advocates and state lawmakers across the country and on Capitol Hill who are working for changes in the law.

Trending Stories

Since his ban from TikTok, Schmidt has continued to use other social media sites to spread his message. After her first account was blocked on the site, she opened a second TikTok, which included a description in the bio that was later deleted: “It’s not a sin to want to be thin.” » Fans of Schmidt’s work mourned his departure from the video app, while critics celebrated it as a sign that tech companies are taking responsibility and enforcing their policies. But as eating disorders remain a hot topic, both online and offline, influencers who promote them will continue to profit. “Influencers undoubtedly make many who follow them feel unattractive. But they can also make you feel that if you watch carefully enough and buy enough good products, you won’t have to feel so bad. They sell body dissatisfaction, but they also sell the dream of being relieved of that dissatisfaction,” Engeln explains. “For many people struggling with body image, consuming content from these influencers is like getting a bruise. You keep pressing on the bruise because a small part of you hopes that one day it won’t hurt as much.

If you suffer from an eating disorder, help is available. Visit the National Eating Disorders Association website to learn about steps you can take to improve, or call the ANAD Helpline at 1 (888) 375-7767.