The Heisman Trophy has increasingly become a “quarterback award.” Since 2000, quarterbacks have won the trophy 19 of 23 times, highlighting the sport’s growing importance on offense and the central role quarterbacks play in a team’s success. This trend has led some to wonder whether the Heisman should broaden its recognition criteria or perhaps establish an award specifically for non-quarterbacks. While quarterbacks undeniably contribute significantly, the game’s other positions are often overlooked, even though they are also instrumental in a team’s success.

Colorado’s Travis Hunter is one of the few non-quarterback athletes seriously fight for the Heisman. The last Colorado player to win this award was running back Rashaan Salaam in 1994, after an outstanding junior season in which he amassed more than 2,000 rushing yards. Hunter, a two-way player who excels at both the wide receiver and cornerback positions, is a unique talent who draws comparisons to head coach Deion Sanders for his versatility on the field. Hunter’s athletic achievements have silenced critics who call him “overrated.”

Pro Football Focus currently ranks him fifth nationally among wide receivers and third among cornerbacks, highlighting his influence on both ends of the field. Hunter, known for responding to his critics, posted a humorous “Overrated Tho” caption on his Instagram, showing his confidence amid criticism.

Only a few non-quarterbacks have won the Heisman in the modern era, with defensive players facing the greatest challenge. Charles Woodson remains the only primarily defensive player to win this award, achieving the feat in 1997 thanks to his remarkable versatility on offense, defense and special teams.

Could voters be split between Hunter and Sanders in the Heisman race?

Woodson’s win over Tennessee quarterback Peyton Manning was groundbreaking, and he has since recognized Hunter as one of the few players to truly excel on both sides of the ball. Hunter’s potential to join this exclusive group highlights the ongoing debate over Heisman criteria and the inherent disadvantage defensive players face.

Despite the odds favoring the quarterbacks, Hunter’s determination keeps him in the race. In a season marked by his athleticism and competitive spirit, Hunter must deliver standout performances in upcoming games to maintain his Heisman momentum. He recognizes that continuing his signature performances will be crucial to winning the nation’s most prestigious college football award, challenging the traditional quarterback narrative and expanding what it means to be “the most outstanding player.”