close
close

Apre-salomemanzo

Breaking: Beyond Headlines!

Key Takeaways from the Supreme Court Judgment in the Safari Retreats Case
aecifo

Key Takeaways from the Supreme Court Judgment in the Safari Retreats Case

CA Madhukar N Hiregange,
CA Anil Bezawada, Advocate, AP High Court

The concept that GST is ONLY a value added tax and therefore the idea that there should be no cascading has been systematically diluted by the CBIC, which has become the de facto legislative authority in GST matters in India. The legislator has almost completely renounced his responsibility. Court decisions are endlessly multiplied and clarity in simple understanding is avoided if it is not in the interest of revenue.

All were awaiting the judgment of the honorable Supreme Court in Safari Retreats. However, it seems that confusions and interpretations have multiplied regarding the ITC’s hold on construction spending. In our opinion, the Supreme Court has clarified certain important points. Some of our views, as we understand them from the judgment of the honorable Supreme Court, are as follows:

Question Answer
1. Can input tax credit be used on goods and services purchased for the construction of a shopping center and intended for rental?
  • Yes. An input tax credit can be used. The restriction in Article 17(5)(d) does not apply where the construction is not for own account.
  • The Hon’ble Supreme Court in paragraph No. 32 of the judgment has held that construction of immovable property intended to be sold or given on lease or license cannot be considered as “for one’s own account”.
  • Furthermore, in such cases, the discussion about the need to satisfy the functionality test is purely theoretical.
2. Can input tax credit be allowed on works contract services received for the construction of a shopping center which is intended to be given on lease/licence?

  • No. In case of services under works contract, the restriction is provided under section 17(5)(c) of the CGST Act, 2017. This is a plain reading.
  • However, it can be argued that the service of works contract is also a ‘service’ by a presumed fiction within the meaning of Entry No. 6(a) of Schedule II of the CGST Act, 2017 and is therefore covered by section 17(5)(d).
  • Once the works contract is also covered by section 17(5)(d), the works contract services used for the construction of the shopping center are also eligible for credit as the shopping center is not for its own account. The GST Ministry would litigate this issue as it litigates in all cases.
  • Now, instead of entrusting construction work on the basis of a works contract, construction materials and services can be purchased independently.
3. Can input tax credit be provided to specialized civil structures which are an integral part of the manufacturing process or which are an integral part of the flow of the manufacturing process? These buildings cannot be separated from the machines and the machines cannot operate without such special construction.
  • Yes. An input tax credit can be used. When a building is planned and constructed in such a way as to meet particular technical requirements, the building qualifies as a facility according to the functionality test laid down by the Supreme Court in various judgments. The technical drawing could support this point of view.
  • The question of whether a construction qualifies as a factory within the meaning of the expression “installation or machinery” must be determined based on the person’s business and the role that this building plays in the business.
  • If the structure is a tool for the company, the one that generates income will not only be treated like a factory.
4. Can input tax credit be given to buildings used for administrative purposes like head office, staff quarters, security rooms, etc.? ?
  • No. Buildings constructed for purely administrative purposes are not considered a factory. They are not planned and built to serve any special technical requirements.
  • The Supreme Court clarified that construction is said to be for the personal benefit of a person if it is used as framework in which the business is carried out.
  • The ITC is not eligible for local purchases of goods or services, nor for services linked to works contracts.
  • The real test is whether your building is intended only to house machines or people (your income generators), the credit is not eligible. However, if the building/structure itself is an income generator, on which you pay the output tax credit, you can claim a credit. (example: as a service provider)
5. Can input tax credit be allowed on goods and services purchased for the construction of a hotel or cinema hall?
  • Considering that a hotel or a cinema hall is not merely a setting in which the business is carried out but a means/tool ​​by which revenue is generated, the honorable Supreme Court will have to decide the eligibility of the ITC for the construction of a hotel or a cinema hall. theater and hotel in light of the specific clauses of section 17(5)(d) of the GST Act, 2017.
  • In our view, the decision in Anand Theaters may not be very relevant in the GST context for various reasons.
6. Is input tax credit eligible on goods and services used for construction of warehouses, cold storages, co-working spaces, dry docks, ponds, parking systems of multi-level car, etc. ?
  • By analogy with the judgment, it can be said that input tax credit is eligible on goods and services used for construction of warehouses, cold rooms, co-working spaces, dry docks, ponds, multi-level car parking systems, etc.
  • The functionality test can be satisfied very easily for these structures.

7. Whether ITC is eligible on elevators, DG sets, escalators, central air conditioning, electrical appliances, sewage treatment plants and water treatment plants.

  • Yes
  • Including civil foundations and structural supports to the above elements

We hope to have provided some clarity on important issues surrounding input tax credit eligibility in light of the Supreme Court judgment. The above views can help assessees to optimize their availment of input tax credit. Those who canceled the ITC under protest or voluntarily can now benefit from this ITC. The ITC relating to the financial year 2023-2024 can be used no later than 30th November 2024.

The basic principle that we are advising since the days of Modvat, Cenvat and now ITC in GST is that whenever there is ambiguity in eligibility for credit/ITC, our suggestion is to avail the credit and fight for credit.

For questions or comments, please contact (email protected)Mobile number 9989604111